YouTube has rejected Senator John McCain’s request for the video website  to consider fair use when responding to DMCA takedown requests.

McCain posted campaign ads with clips from CBS and Fox news broadcasts. The two networks sent YouTube takedown notices, which according to the DMCA, they are legally obliged to respond to immediately in order to maintain safe harbor protections.  McCain voted for the DMCA in 1998 and now has to deal with the consequences.

This shows McCain and few in Congress truly understood the effects of the DMCA and likely the same can be said for most complex laws put on their desks.  The DMCA includes the excellent safe harbor provision that protects platforms from being liable for what users do (like YouTube shouldn’t be liable for copyright infringement of its users).  But the takedown notices have become an abused system stifling free expression and negative opinions. This is not to mention how anti-circumvention laws violate upheld fair use rights and stifle innovation.

When first passed, Congress probably thought they were protecting intellectual property. Their intentions might even have been noble. But these under-thought, one-sided laws are going to hurt innovation and creativity. And you could argue it’s hurting democracy. McCain can’t even get his own campaign ads on YouTube because the site is too scared of being sued over copyright infringement (too late).

Too often laws are passed to pander “look what I did” rather than look what we accomplished.  Did the admittedly rushed Patriot Act (which many politicians never finished reading) compromise our rights too much to keep us safe? How much is the new PRO-IP law’s Copyright Czar going to stop piracy? And when is this bailout bill going to turn my 401k into 401 million?

McCain shouldn’t be looking for special treatment from YouTube.  He wants to be president, so why doesn’t he act like a leader and champion changing a bad law? I don’t want a politician to have their own class of laws; I want them to make the laws we all have better.  We’ve got to stop and smell the roses, before we accidently ban them.